It's never a good sign when you and your eight best friends are drunk, shouting, and standing in front of a federal judge. Except this one time.
We were at Peter Luger in Brooklyn for our annual Man of the Year dinner, voting on which of our childhood friends had the best year. For the first time ever, the vote was tied. Nine grown men were arguing like it was the Supreme Court. A 91-year-old federal judge at the next table, trying to enjoy dinner with his grandkids, walked over. Instead of scolding us, his eyes lit up. "I'll settle this." Karo and I made our closing arguments. Karo won. I'm still not over it.
That tradition is why my childhood friends are still my friends. Here's how it started, and how to build one of your own.
How Man of the Year started
More than 20 years ago, our crew from Long Island had a Friendsgiving dinner at Peter Luger. Somebody joked about who'd had the best year. Karo, our group historian, wrote down the "winner." The next year we did it again. Then we had a trophy made: a ridiculous, half-Stanley-Cup-sized chalice with room for 36 years of names.
Now, every Tuesday before Thanksgiving, nine of us fly in from around the country, walk into Luger's with the trophy, and vote. The winner gets his name engraved and keeps the trophy for a year. There's one unwritten rule: anyone can have a kid. (I welcomed a baby boy one year and did not win. Still bitter.)
The dinner is great. But the real magic is the other 364 days: the group chat lobbying, the trash talk, the updates on everyone's wins and losses.
Why traditions work
They take the guesswork out. Nobody has to ask "when are we getting together?" The date is set.
They future-proof your friendships. I know where I'll be in 50 years: at that table, arguing about whose grandkid had the best year.
They create stickiness. A ritual is the glue that holds a group together through moves, marriages, kids and busy seasons.
They get more sacred over time. Luger's started as "I hope I can make it." Now it's "unless I'm in the hospital, I'm there."
How to start yours
1. Start small and weekly. A standing coffee, a Thursday pickleball game, a weekly video update in the group chat. Small rituals build the habit.
2. Try a gateway ritual. Fantasy football is the classic for a reason: an annual draft, weekly matchups, months of built-in reasons to talk smack. March Madness brackets, an Oscars pool or even a fantasy Bachelor league work the same way. The event matters less than the regular contact.
3. Then go annual. This is where the magic happens. Some ideas from our listeners and friends:
A yearly fishing, ski or camping trip (one listener's crew is 15 years in)
A reunion weekend in a rented cabin
The same college football game every season
A joint milestone-birthday trip
My wife and her friends take an annual trip and sew a patch from each destination onto matching jackets
4. Ritualize the ritual. Give it a name. Make T-shirts. Build a trophy. A group chat with a name and a logo feels like a club. A random dinner feels optional. (For more ideas, grab The Friendship Ritual Toolkit.)
5. Get buy-in at home. A tradition with the partners' blessing is basically indestructible. The year my wife was pregnant with our first, I started talking myself out of going to Luger's. She went online, bought my plane ticket and said, "Be back in 48 hours."
Remember to have fun
Somewhere between our twenties and our forties, a lot of men decided they don't have time for fun with their friends, or don't need it. You do, and you deserve it. Traditions turn "we should hang out more" into something you can't skip.
Thanksgiving week is the perfect time to start. Text your group tonight: "Same time next year?" Then put it on the calendar.
For more on building a circle worth celebrating, read how to make friends as an adult.
Want the whole system? This post is adapted from The Buddy System: A Modern Man's Guide to Mastering Friendship and Leveling Up Your Life, the Audible Original I wrote and narrated with my best friend since second grade, Aaron Karo. Listen on Audible.
For one small friendship move in your inbox every week, join The Friendship Habit.
Matt Ritter, The Friendship Guy